The sound was more than a little daunting. A nondescript voice called to the intersection of 4th Avenue and Atlantic Avenue in Brooklyn, NY, asking that those within hearing range come to pray toward Mecca. I walked with my husband toward the world’s busiest Target, while somewhere down Atlantic, knees were being bowed in prayer toward a foreign deity.
At least, that’s what my thought was. Later in the evening I visited with two locals who each offered separate perspectives on the same event–or at least, the same sound at perhaps a different time. Over the course of dinner and a resounding game of Taboo, I’d enjoyed the company of these women who shared my basic religious beliefs and a European heritage, and over peppered popcorn, one of the two (I’ll call her M) asked the other (S) if she’d heard the sounds from the nearby mosque. S shared that she had and found the noise disconcerting; I had as well, being unfamiliar with the language and unnerved that one religion could exercise this freedom while others would be the objects of political and media outrage if they flooded the streets with bullhorns of theology. S later commented on her pride in knowing that America allowed for such diversities as religious freedom, though our own was often excluded. Then M said something that has stayed with me for the past few days–”Still, I try to not walk that way. Their theology is so anti-American; I don’t want to get shot.” (my best attempt at a direct quotation).
As one single verse kept ringing in my ears, I quieted my tongue, hoping to simply end the conversation and get back to Taboo. Other thoughts arose–thoughts of The Crusades, 9/11, movies I’d seen about Muslims (Traitor, Not Without My Daughter, etc…), and the fully covered women walking the streets of New York. I know that many religions have their passive and aggressive members. I know that for residents of America and New York, especially, the hostility exhibited in the 9/11 attacks will be forever etched in our minds. I know that calm Muslims can be violent. I know that Muslims recruited for violence can save lives. I know that I have my freedom of religion only if they also have their freedom. I know that I could get shot.
Still, the knowledge of physical danger struck me as unique to hear from a Christian. I’m in as much danger to be shot by a Muslim as I am to be shot by a white/black/hispanic/Asian/Christian/Buddhist/any-living-person, but physical danger is hardly what scares me most.
“Do not be afraid of those who kill the body but cannot kill the soul. Rather, be afraid of the one who can destroy both soul and body in hell” (Matthew 10:28). In the life of a Christian, fear of Muslims should only happen in the case that we fear who they serve. Yes, in serving that deity, some may decide to be physically violent, but a Christian’s soul will remain safe in the event that she gets shot or blown up or ridiculed.
I am hardly the example of someone who is quick to see the soul in people rather than their appearance or actions, but as I meditate on the above verse, I know what would be the greater tragedy. If walking past the Mosque daily, talking, singing, and shining light in that dark place means getting shot, my soul would remain secure and I might just have the chance to rescue the soul of another. If, however, I take the long way to the store, hiding from the remote possibility that I will endure physical pain, wouldn’t that be like the Rabbi walking past the bleeding Jew? I’d rather be a dead light than the villain in the Good Samaritan story.